Scuttlebutt Website SCUTTLEBUTT
WEBSITE
ForumIndex FORUM
INDEX
Search Posts SEARCH
POSTS
Who's Online WHO'S
ONLINE
Log in LOG IN         

Forum Index: DISCUSSION: Dock Talk:
The US Sailing Team - Does One Size Fit All?
Team McLube

 

 


The Publisher
*****


Oct 12, 2010, 3:05 PM

Post #1 of 5 (2920 views)
Shortcut
The US Sailing Team - Does One Size Fit All? Log-In to Post/Reply

Olympic and World Champion John Bertrand (USA), who now can be found coaching aspiring sailors, posted this commentary on his blog Bertrand Racing:

THE US SAILING TEAM - DOES ONE SIZE FIT ALL?
(posted in Scuttlebutt 3196)

The cover story for this month's Sailing World Magazine, "Stress Test," highlights the changes within the US Sailing Team AlphaGraphics for this Olympic cycle. It is an insider's look by reporter Stuart Streuli, who spent time with the team at a physical training camp at the US Olympic training center in Colorado Springs last March, and at the Kiel Week regatta in June. Streuli gives a glowing review of the new direction and philosophy that Olympic Sailing Director, Dean Brenner, and head coach, Kenneth Andreasen, are taking.

Stressing team unity and overall fitness are cornerstones of their approach. However, I was dismayed to read that certain sailors on the team were singled out for not being team players, allegedly hurting the US team's chances for medals at the 2012 Olympic Games. The sailors singled out included the very talented young sailor I have been coaching in the Finn, Luke Lawrence.

In Luke's case, nothing could be further from the truth. Why would the "Brass" at the Olympic Sailing Committee go public with such an allegation? I believe this sentiment revolves around a management philosophy and mindset akin to the infamous statement "you are either with us, or against us." I believe it highlights a glaring weakness in understanding, and also a lack of desire to understand how to effectively develop an individual's potential within a team environment. In others words, does one size fit all?

Streuli writes that:
"Not everything that Andreasen and Brenner touch turns to gold - literally or figuratively..... A big part of the USSTAG's new culture is intra-squad training; all the U.S. sailors within a specific class working together under a common coach for a large part of the Olympic cycle..... Erin Maxwell and 2004 Olympian Isabelle Kingsolving won the 2008 Women's 470 World Championship. Amanda Clark and Sarah Chin finished 12th in the 2008 Olympics. Together they could form a potent training duo. However to date they haven't trained together. USSTAG officials imply this is due to a personality conflict...."

"The same can be said of Luke Lawrence, a confident Floridian who won the Laser silver medal at the 2008 ISAF Volvo Youth World Championships. In his first Finn regatta, the 2010 Rolex Miami OCR, he finished in the top half of the 37-boat fleet. But, unhappy with the attention he received from Andreasen at the first two European regattas of the 2010 season, he hired 1984 silver medalist John Bertrand as his personal coach, isolating himself from the rest of the U.S. team. It appears to have benefited Lawrence, who won the Finn Junior World Championship in San Francisco in August, in the short term. But will it hurt the U.S. team's medal hopes (and those of Lawrence) in 2012 and further down the road?"

Much more here: http://johnbertrand.blogspot.com/2010/10/blog-post.html




The Publisher
*****


Oct 12, 2010, 3:07 PM

Post #2 of 5 (2909 views)
Shortcut
Re: [The Publisher] The US Sailing Team - Does One Size Fit All? [In reply to] Log-In to Post/Reply

Dean Brenner, US Olympic and Paralympic Sailing Program Chairman, provides this reply to John Bertrand's statements:

In Scuttlebutt issue 3196, the lead story was an excerpted blog post with some opinions and statements about the US Sailing Team AlphaGraphics, some of our athletes and the new culture we have instituted. While each of us is entitled to our own opinion, we are not entitled to our own facts. And, quite simply, there were several factual inaccuracies that should be corrected.

Luke Lawrence is a member of the 2010 US Sailing Development Team. Period. And, as far as we are concerned, he’ll be on the team for the remainder of the year unless he chooses to step aside. We think Luke is a great talent, and we hope he’ll apply again for the team in 2011. We’ve never kicked him off the team, we’ve never asked him to resign, and we’ve never excluded him from any team meetings, barbecues, or training sessions. The blog post in question made lots of statements about his removal and exclusion from the Team. I was surprised to read that, it was news to me, and I maintain a complete open door policy to chat with any sailor at any time about anything that concerns them.

Our Development Team is intended to be a path for young sailors to learn to compete as Olympic athletes… something that Olympic sailing in the USA has been in desperate need of for a long time, and that we are proud to have created. We give them coaching and lots of other kinds of support, and we give them opportunities to train alongside and learn from our top athletes, like Finn Silver Medalist Zach Railey. We look for developing athletes who have the skills and the commitment to be a part of this team, and if they want to take advantage of the opportunity, we welcome them with open arms. If they would rather go their own way, then that’s fine also. We’ll cheer just as loudly for any athlete who would prefer to follow their own path and who finds a way to win an Olympic medal on their own. If Luke chooses his own path, then that is great. On the other hand, if he wants to take advantage of the opportunities on our Development Team, then that’s great also. Either way, we will cheer his success.

We believe strongly in the system and culture that we are building on our Development Team and on the US Sailing Team AlphaGraphics. We believe that shared training and a collaborative culture is better for everyone. We believe it helps stretch our resources further. We believe it creates a better environment for our sailors. And we believe it creates something that sponsors, donors and fans can embrace.

We have a system, and it is an entirely new culture. But it’s not for everyone. It would be impossible to create a structured system that also caters to every specific need of every athlete. And with about 100 hyper-competitive, goal-oriented athletes on our teams, it’s also unrealistic to expect that all of them will love everything that we do. But we do believe that a system is necessary, and if someone wants to work outside the system, at the end of the day, the sailors on the 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Teams are still representing the USA and we’ll be there alongside them, cheering and supporting.

One of the key issues with our system, however, is the role of the private coach. We work hard to hire staff and per diem coaches who believe in our new culture and can have a positive effect on both their athlete(s) and the entire team at the Olympics. In the lead-up to the Games, the role of the private coach is an issue when staff coaching is present at the same event. We understand full well that some athletes will want or need some additional, personal support. Those private coaches are welcomed into our training and our meetings, with a few specific requirements. The coach has to be trustworthy, has to be a team player, and we won’t hesitate to respectfully exclude someone whom we determine, in consultation with other athletes on our team, would have a negative impact in any way on our culture, training and effectiveness.

Finally, I want to applaud our Finn results over the last two years. The record speaks for itself and we have a world-class Finn program in the USA for the first time in a long time. That’s a credit first and foremost to our sailors, but also to our coaches and our friends in the Finn class who have worked so hard to make USA success in the Finn a reality.

Respectfully,
Dean Brenner
Chairman
US Olympic and Paralympic Sailing Program




John Tormey
***


Oct 12, 2010, 4:50 PM

Post #3 of 5 (2899 views)
Shortcut
Re: [The Publisher] The US Sailing Team - Does One Size Fit All? [In reply to] Log-In to Post/Reply

Thank you John Bertrand for creating some interest in Olympic sailing (in Scuttlebutt 3196). For whatever reason, Olympic sailing in the U.S. lives in the shadow of I don’t know what. There is only so many ways to get the spotlight to turn your way, and creating a soap opera is very popular these days. Bertrand’s complaints about USSTAG likely have some validity, but when is everyone in team sports happy? Plus, what are the odds that Bertrand and team chairman Dean Brenner have become Facebook friends since the 2008 U.S. Olympic Trials and the Farrah Hall conflict? Remember that Hall fled to Bertrand following the redress mess, who then helped her retaliate against U.S. SAILING. War wounds heal slowly.




BADDOGFINNUSA13
*

Oct 13, 2010, 8:43 AM

Post #4 of 5 (2291 views)
Shortcut
Re: [The Publisher] The US Sailing Team - Does One Size Fit All? [In reply to] Log-In to Post/Reply

Funny I didn't see you address the fact that the coach would not..."NOT"...allow them to attend meetings and practice....I should have known it was going to be double talk when you used the political line of "you can't make up your own facts"...or some such dribble then instead of actually taking each accusation and debunking it ...you go to double speak and in the end pretty much leave a door open to again leave the up and comer out...you would have been much better served by keeping your mouth shut in this case…

It does seem it would have made the team better had you accepted...Mr. Bertrand’s offer of help...as his coaching Luke seemed to have shown much better results...Time to stop playing personalities and start playing to win the Olympic Medals…

JUST SAYIN...

BAD DOG USA 13


The Publisher
*****


Oct 13, 2010, 5:25 PM

Post #5 of 5 (2075 views)
Shortcut
Re: [The Publisher] The US Sailing Team - Does One Size Fit All? [In reply to] Log-In to Post/Reply

SCUTTLEBUTT 3198 - Thursday, October 14, 2010

* From Rob Anderson:
Reading John Bertrand’s plaintive missive, I had to chuckle at life’s little ironies. Though it’s been over 25 years, it was powerful forces within US Sailing that were instrumental in installing John as the Finn representative for the ’84 games in LA. I certainly hope that John’s young protégé is not treated as poorly as the sailors that were on the wrong side of that train wreck so many years ago.


* From Ron Rosenberg:
Earlier this quad I was warmly welcomed into Kenneth's program as a private coach, and he and his staff coaches immediately made me and many other private coaches feel very comfortable working alongside them.

Since 1984, I've been continually and closely involved with the US Sailing Team either as a sailor, a staff coach, or a private coach for USSTAG athletes and others. Over the years the team policy on private coaches has varied a little, but for the most part the team has generally made an effort to encourage, support and work with those private coaches that share the common goal to help the athletes improve in an efficient manner and to help them reach their potential.

I believe that there has never been a better time to be a member of the USSTAG or a Dev Team member. The high level of support, resources, energy and opportunities that this USSTAG have provided these athletes with is simply unprecedented in this country.





Viewing the Forums: No members and 844 guests
 
 


Search for (options) Contact Forum Forum FAQS Markup Tags Forum Rules