Scuttlebutt Website SCUTTLEBUTT
WEBSITE
ForumIndex FORUM
INDEX
Search Posts SEARCH
POSTS
Who's Online WHO'S
ONLINE
Log in LOG IN         

Forum Index: DISCUSSION: Dock Talk:
Dumbing down of the mighty 18 Foot skiff
Team McLube

 

 


atefooterz
***


Dec 15, 2010, 6:47 AM

Post #1 of 1 (2447 views)
Shortcut
Dumbing down of the mighty 18 Foot skiff Log-In to Post/Reply

Dear Julian you posted ... in Scuttlebutt 3240


Quote
* From Julian Bethwaite, Sydney Australia:
The International Moth class, a development class, is deliberating on
possibly restricting development in their class. Though the particular
question at issue isn't important per say, the issue is wing masts.

For what it is worth, it matters not what the rules are, or whose set of
rules you use because the perception of the Moth class has been one that I
believe a great number of sailors who have never sailed a Moth aspire to.
The Moth is in a rarefied field, along with the A class, C class,
International Canoes and a class dear to my heart, which used to belong to
your group, but has dropped out the bottom, - the 18teen.

And this is my point: What the class executive committee is about to do is
make a decision that has very long term effects and will position the Moth
class as either the utopia that we all aspire to, or just another class.

In 1996-7 a gentleman called Antony James Reynolds made what was effectively
a personal attack on me, which set a course of demise of the 18teen to where
it is today rather than where it could have been.

Sorry, it's not a $$$ thing as an I14 is five times the cost of a 49er and
they are doing very well, thank you very much. And obsolescence does not cut
it either. Moths have an ethos of evolution. If you kill that, you kill the
class.

While the JJ Giltinan for the 18teen is still a very worthy trophy to win,
there simply are no new Bruce Farr's, Ben Lexan's, Iain Murray or dare I say
Julian Bethwaite's coming from what used to be called "the Hot House
Flowers" of the sailing world.

We now are looking at the Mac's and the Bora's of this world along with the
Rohan Veal's & Fred Eaton's to show us the future. Hopefully!



Going off topic from the Moth Class content, what you have stated about 18`s is such an oversimplification & ignoring of major issues within the class and NSW 18`League V The Grand Prix Circuit, that it makes you look like the Chinese Govt explaining the Tienaman Square "rukkus" and their spin doctors would be applauding you !

Please post something that represents at least partial history that the Class suffrered via the self serving interests of Reynolds , Holmes , Queally & Winning and the greed of Macartney, Brown & Co ... chasing Olympic $, that ultimatly led to the current bastardisation that is the Woody IOD 18 Footer !

As Nokia themselves discovered, when a young Witty won the 2 rig 14` wingspan JJ`s , as opposed to the televised 18` wing spanned 3 rigged Prudential won the Grand Prix ... Nokia who ??? ...what is the NSW League??? ... and where did the sponser $$ go that next season ?
"White knuckle fast to furious Bethwaite & any other designer who could do, style 18s ..thats where the money went !

Where did the Class go ? up the Pros bum, most who left faster than rats on sinking ships when the cash went dry and over to IOD 18s deep pockets land !




twitter @8footerz




Viewing the Forums: No members and 1057 guests
 
 


Search for (options) Contact Forum Forum FAQS Markup Tags Forum Rules