Scuttlebutt Website SCUTTLEBUTT
WEBSITE
ForumIndex FORUM
INDEX
Search Posts SEARCH
POSTS
Who's Online WHO'S
ONLINE
Log in LOG IN         

Forum Index: DISCUSSION: Dock Talk:
Cost to compete at Youth Worlds
Team McLube

 

 


The Publisher
*****


Jul 27, 2010, 10:46 AM

Post #1 of 2 (2301 views)
Shortcut
Cost to compete at Youth Worlds Log-In to Post/Reply

The 40th Volvo Youth Sailing ISAF World Championship was held July 8-17, 2010 in Istanbul, Turkey, attracting nearly 350 young sailors from 59 nations. Among the nations was New Zealand, which fielded a complete team of 11 sailors for the 8 events. This perennial favorite was one of five countries to win two medals (Boys Laser Radial - Gold, 29er - Silver), bested only by the three medals won by the USA. But competing at this elite event comes with a cost, as detailed here by Grant Beck, whose son Logan competed in the Boys 420 class:



The cost to the NZ Yachting Federation and the parents was about $150,000 for this great event when you include the cost of training back home and any racing in Europe before hand (Yup NZ is a long way away and it’s a big deal for us to compete in Europe).

Only 7 of 12 races could be completed at the 2010 Worlds due to light winds. A similar thing occurred at the 2009 Youth Worlds in Brazil when only 8 of the 12 races were sailed.

The cost of each race to the NZ team is $12,500.00 per race so to miss out on 5 races is a $62,500.00 cost, and, when you consider a similar cost per race to many of the sailors from the other 58 countries, it sure adds up.

Now we all know we can’t go racing when the wind is too light, shifty or for that matter too strong. However, for two years in a row only just over half the racing has been completed. This isn’t good enough when you count the cost in terms of money, time, effort, and the prestige this event has.

Fixing this is easy! Make the racing the absolute priority. Every opportunity should be taken to race; that’s to use the lay days, re-scheduling racing if required and perhaps the addition of a spare day as the marginal cost of providing additional reserve days is negligible as a completed race schedule is the key goal.


Curmudgeon’s Comment: The 2010 event was hot with light winds, and racing was often postponed and ended quite late in the day. I have a hunch that Grant is eyeing the Lay Day as wasted time, and also how the last day provided the best breeze day, but only one race was completed. Also, to clarify the completed race count, three of the eight classes in 2010 completed seven races, with only one class topping out at ten races. Here was the original schedule:

09 July - Training Day
10 July - Practice Races
11 July - 3 Races scheduled (2 to 3 races completed)
12 July - 3 Races scheduled (1 to 2 races completed)
13 July - Lay Day
14 July - 3 Races scheduled (0 to 1 race completed)
15 July - 2 Races scheduled (2 to 3 races completed)
16 July - 1 Race scheduled (1 race completed)

Event website: http://www.isafyouthworlds.com/editions/2010/index.php



ms
*****

Aug 2, 2010, 12:01 PM

Post #2 of 2 (2163 views)
Shortcut
Re: Cost to compete at Youth Worlds [In reply to] Log-In to Post/Reply

From Robert Wilkes (re, Scuttlebutt 3144):

I suggest Al Johnson’s comments in Butt 3144 have got it the wrong way round. The large and increasing number of participants in Optimists events is, at least in part, the result of sailing organisations creating the LEAST expensive game possible. Some of his remarks show how little he has studied the realities of these events and the efforts “sailing organizations” make to reduce costs. For example:

- Participants DON’T have to send their boats thousands of miles. At all three named events (and many others) fully competitive charter boats are available from as little as USD 300.

- The cost of sending coaches is reduced by the fact that only one coach per ten sailors at the North Americans and one for the entire team at the Europeans is allowed on the water, and each coach must share a support boat with another coach thus halving the cost of same.

- Entry fees at these two events are kept very low, providing racing, lodging and all meals for under USD80 per day. My guess is that this is a lot cheaper than many summer camps.

- The IODA calendar is normally scheduled so that it is impossible for the same sailors to participate in both the N. Americans and the Europeans, so no parent has to pay for both for the same sailor. And kids who go to the Europeans are not allowed to go to the Worlds. -- Edited to the 250 word limit, read on at:

Travel is of course the same for all the many sports that hold national and continental championships.

If parents are willing to spend “a chunk of their money on their children’s racing exploits” that is their choice. One can imagine many worse things they could place on that silver platter. And it is grossly unfair to criticize not-for-profit, largely volunteer sailing organizations for being successful at providing low-cost high-quality events that attract ever higher numbers.


Viewing the Forums: No members and 827 guests
 
 


Search for (options) Contact Forum Forum FAQS Markup Tags Forum Rules